HEART & SOUL, 4-CD BOX SET (London Records 828 968-2, 1997)
This is an official release and highly recommended for any Joy Division collector.
The tables below show where the tracks have been officially released before. If the tracks haven't been officially
released before then links to bootleg information are given.
This set includes a nice 84 page booklet.
Click here for a review
Click here for a list of tracks that weren't included
Disc 1 - all tracks previously available
| |
Track |
... was previously released on these records / notes |
| 1 |
Digital |
A Factory Sample |
|
Substance |
| 2 |
Glass |
A Factory Sample |
Still |
Substance |
| 3 |
Disorder |
Unknown Pleasures |
|
|
| 4 |
Day of the Lords |
Unknown Pleasures |
Permanent |
|
| 5 |
Candidate |
Unknown Pleasures |
|
|
| 6 |
Insight |
Unknown Pleasures |
|
|
| 7 |
New Dawn Fades |
Unknown Pleasures |
|
|
| 8 |
She's Lost Control |
Unknown Pleasures |
Permanent |
|
| 9 |
Shadowplay |
Unknown Pleasures |
Permanent |
|
| 10 |
Wilderness |
Unknown Pleasures |
|
|
| 11 |
Interzone |
Unknown Pleasures |
|
|
| 12 |
I Remember Nothing |
Unknown Pleasures |
|
|
| 13 |
Ice Age |
|
Still |
(Added post production) |
| 14 |
Exercise One |
|
Still |
(Added post production) |
| 15 |
Transmission |
7"&12" single |
Permanent |
Substance |
| 16 |
Novelty |
7"&12" single B-side |
Permanent |
Substance |
| 17 |
The Kill |
|
Still |
(Added post production) |
| 18 |
The Only Mistake |
7"&12" single B-side '88 |
Still, Permanent |
(Added post production) |
| 19 |
Something Must Break |
|
Still, Permanent |
(Added post production) |
| 20 |
Auto-Suggestion |
Earcom 2 |
Substance |
|
| 21 |
From Safety to Where...? |
Earcom 2 |
Substance |
|
(Later compilation appearances featuring any of the above songs have not been included in the "Also released
on" section of this listing)
Note: 'Walked In Line' from the "Unknown Pleasures" session at Strawberry
Studios in April '79 should have been featured on Disc One, but had to be included on Disc 3 instead for reasons
of space.
Disc 2 - all tracks previously available
| |
Track |
... was previously released on these records |
| 1 |
She's Lost Control |
12" single A-side |
12" B-side |
Substance |
|
| 2 |
The Sound of Music |
12" single B-side '88 |
Still |
|
|
| 3 |
Atmosphere |
Sordide 7", 12" single |
Substance |
|
Permanent |
| 4 |
Dead Souls |
Sordide 7" B-side |
Substance |
Still |
Permanent |
| 5 |
Komakino |
Flexi disc |
Substance |
|
|
| 6 |
Incubation |
Flexi disc B-side |
Substance |
|
|
| 7 |
Atrocity Exhibition |
Closer |
|
|
|
| 8 |
Isolation |
Closer |
|
|
Permanent |
| 9 |
Passover |
Closer |
|
|
Permanent |
| 10 |
Colony |
Closer |
|
|
|
| 11 |
A Means to an End |
Closer |
|
|
|
| 12 |
Heart and Soul |
Closer |
|
|
Permanent |
| 13 |
Twenty Four Hours |
Closer |
|
|
Permanent |
| 14 |
The Eternal |
Closer |
|
|
|
| 15 |
Decades |
Closer |
|
|
|
| 16 |
Love Will Tear us Apart |
7" & 12" single |
Substance |
|
|
| 17 |
These Days |
7" & 12" single B-side |
Substance |
Permanent |
|
(Later compilation appearances featuring any of the above songs have not been included in the "Also released
on" section of this listing)
Note: 'Ice Age', despite having been recorded in October 1979 during the same session that produced 'Atmosphere'
and 'Dead Souls', was not thought to belong on this CD, and is included on Disc 1 instead. Even if 'Ice Age' was
not recorded for possible release until Oct. '79 it is a very early JD (possibly even Warsaw) song written in late
'77 or early '78. An early version appeared on the RCA session from early May '78,
and musically as well as lyrically it is safe to say that it belongs on Disc 1.
Disc 3 - includes sixteen unreleased studio recordings
| |
Track |
... was previously released on these records |
Date |
Source |
| 1 |
Warsaw |
An Ideal for Living |
Substance |
12-77 |
Pennine Studio |
| 2 |
No Love Lost |
An Ideal for Living |
Substance |
12-77 |
Pennine Studio |
| 3 |
Leaders of Men |
An Ideal for Living |
Substance |
12-77 |
Pennine Studio |
| 4 |
Failures |
An Ideal for Living |
Substance |
12-77 |
Pennine Studio |
| 5 |
The Drawback |
Previously unreleased |
aborted LP project |
05-78 |
RCA Demo |
| 6 |
Interzone |
Previously unreleased |
aborted LP project |
05-78 |
RCA Demo |
| 7 |
Shadowplay |
Previously unreleased |
aborted LP project |
05-78 |
RCA Demo |
| 8 |
Exercise One |
John Peel Sessions |
First John Peel Session |
01-79 |
BBC studio |
| 9 |
Insight |
Previously unreleased |
Genetic demo |
03-79 |
Eden studio |
| 10 |
Glass |
Previously unreleased |
Genetic demo |
03-79 |
Eden studio |
| 11 |
Transmission |
Previously unreleased |
Genetic demo |
03-79 |
Eden studio |
| 12 |
Dead Souls |
Previously unreleased |
|
07-79 |
Central sound |
| 13 |
Something Must Break |
Raw mix of Still version |
(No added post production) |
07-79 |
Central sound |
| 14 |
Ice Age |
Previously unreleased |
Genetic demo |
03-79 |
Eden studio |
| 15 |
Walked in Line |
Raw mix of Still version |
(No added post production) |
04-79 |
Strawberry studio |
| 16 |
These Days |
Previously unreleased |
|
06-79 |
Piccadilly radio |
| 17 |
Candidate |
Previously unreleased |
|
06-79 |
Piccadilly radio |
| 18 |
The Only Mistake |
Previously unreleased |
|
06-79 |
Piccadilly radio |
| 19 |
Chance (Atmosphere) |
Previously unreleased |
|
06-79 |
Piccadilly radio |
| 20 |
Love Will Tear us Apart |
John Peel Sessions |
Second John Peel session |
11-79 |
BBC studio |
| 21 |
Colony |
John Peel Sessions |
Second John Peel session |
11-79 |
BBC studio |
| 22 |
As You Said |
Flexi uncredited track |
N. ORDER-Video 586 12" |
03-80 |
Britannia Row |
| 23 |
Ceremony |
Previously unreleased |
from a rehearsal tape |
04-80 |
Graveyard studio |
| 24 |
In a Lonely Place (detail) |
Previously unreleased |
from a rehearsal tape |
04-80 |
Graveyard studio |
Notes: The "Still" version of 'Walked In Line' originates from the Strawberry
Studio sessions in April 1979, but due to lack of studio time, as well as this song not being among the 10
tracks chosen to be included on "Unknown Pleasures", it was left unfinished. When Factory in 1981 decided
to release the unissued JD studio material on the posthumous "Still" double album some or all of the
remaining JD-members went into the studio with Martin Hannett to put the finishing touches on the tracks that were
left unfinished, 'Walked In Line' being one of these tracks. The box-set version of WIL is the original raw mix
of the song, as recorded in '79. The version on "Still" has some extra guitar and added production from
Hannett.
Many of the unreleased tracks from this disc appear on the Soul and Heart pirate LP
Disc 4 - features live unreleased tracks.
Notes: 'Shadowplay' from The Factory (Russell Club), Manchester 13th July 1979
was for some reason not included here, and it remains the only song from this gig that has not yet been released.
'Transmission' - the final encore from this concert - was a bonus track on the 1988 reissue of 'Atmosphere' (on
the CD issue only).
Heart And Soul; the ultimate - and so far only - JD box-set. Spread over 4 CDs we get
just about every officially released JD song, one full CD of mostly rare and previously unissued material, and
one concert disc featuring previously unreleased live versions.
Disc One, or "Unknown Pleasures Plus", brings together JD's first Factory album as the title suggests,
out-takes from the UP sessions that later surfaced on "Still", a few compilation
tracks and the 'Transmission'/'Novelty' single. As they're all more or less from the same period, collecting all
these songs on one CD works really well.
Disc 2, or "Closer Plus", features material recorded in 1980 or late 1979, and brings together the
"Closer" album and great singles like 'Love Will Tear Us Apart' and 'Atmosphere', as well as some out-takes
and a re-recorded version of 'She's Lost Control'. Needless to say; this is brilliant collection of exceptional
songs.
Disc 3, or "Rarities", is the collection of hard to find tracks many JD collectors and long-time fans
have been waiting for. As well as containing the 4 songs from JD's first EP "An Ideal For Living" and
songs from the much-bootlegged RCA Arrow Studios sessions in May 1978, we also get
material that has never been in circulation before, not even among the most ardent JD tape collectors. The 4 Genetic demos from March 1979 offer alternative if not terribly different, but none the
less very interesting studio versions of songs like 'Transmission' and 'Insight'. Another definite highlight of
this CD is the rehearsal room recording of 'Ceremony' and 'In A Lonely Place' (detail). The latter is missing the
final verse, either due to reasons of taste (the "hangman" line being judged as too controversial or
upsetting perhaps) or simply because the tape ran out during the recording or so the story goes, depending on who
you want to believe. The sound quality of these two tracks leaves something to be desired, but as the only JD "studio"
versions of these two songs they are essential listening for any serious JD fan.
Disc 4, or "Live", contains previously unreleased live material from 1979 and 1980. The sound quality
of the live material isn't quite as good as what one might expect from a professionally recorded live album, but
all in all not too bad. Some or most of the live material originate from audience recordings, but the quality of
these performances make them fascinating to listen to all the same. It would have been nice if London Records had
decided to include some exclusive live material on Disc 4 though, Peter Hook's private live tapes collection would
have been a good place to start looking for some gems. All four live concerts that are featured on "Heart
And Soul" have been in circulation among tape collectors for years, and the lack of any previously unheard
live material is a little bit disappointing. Particularly as Hooky has played tracks from undistributed live tapes
on the radio, so there are definitely more JD live recordings in existence.
The accompanying booklet is very nice too, with lyrics, a detailed discography, a sessionography and a biography.
Also featured is an English translation of the essays which was originally printed in the folder of the limited
"Licht Und Blindheit" issue on the French label Sordide Sentimental. There's also a rather obscure piece
by Paul Morley, which you'll either love it or hate depending on how you like his style of writing. They also had
the great idea of reproducing the Jon Savage JD feature that originally appeared in the Mojo magazine in 1994;
a very interesting and well-researched article indeed. The picture of Ian Curtis on the front cover of the box
is a strange choice though. With so many other great, if maybe a bit too familiar pictures available of IC and
the rest of the band it's weird that they would choose this still picture from a TV appearance on BBC2 in 1979,
in which Ian hardly looks his best.
All in all this is an essential purchase for any JD fan. If you haven't got it already you should pick it up;
this box set is highly recommended!
Reviewed by Erik
What was left off:
Below is a list of the studio material and previously released live recordings that were left off the "Heart
And Soul" box-set.
Note: Dates are in European format 18-07-77 is 18th July 1977
| Date |
Title |
Source/Issue |
Place |
Comments |
| 18-07-77 |
Inside The Line |
The "Warsaw" demo |
Pennine Sound Studios |
see Bootlegs |
| 18-07-77 |
Gutz |
The "Warsaw" demo |
Pennine Sound Studios |
see Bootlegs |
| 18-07-77 |
At A Later Date |
The "Warsaw" demo |
Pennine Sound Studios |
see Bootlegs |
| 18-07-77 |
The Kill |
The "Warsaw" demo |
Pennine Sound Studios |
see Bootlegs |
| 18-07-77 |
You're No Good For Me |
The "Warsaw" demo |
Pennine Sound Studios |
see Bootlegs |
| 02-10-77 |
At A Later Date (live) |
Short Circuit 10" LP |
Electric Circus, Manchester |
Virgin compilation LP |
| 03-05-78 |
Leaders Of Men |
RCA album sessions |
Arrow Studios, Manchester |
see Bootlegs |
| 03-05-78 |
Walked In Line |
RCA album sessions |
Arrow Studios, Manchester |
see Bootlegs |
| 03-05-78 |
Failures |
RCA album sessions |
Arrow Studios, Manchester |
see Bootlegs |
| 03-05-78 |
Novelty |
RCA album sessions |
Arrow Studios, Manchester |
see Bootlegs |
| 04-05-78 |
No Love Lost |
RCA album sessions |
Arrow Studios, Manchester |
see Bootlegs |
| 04-05-78 |
Transmission |
RCA album sessions |
Arrow Studios, Manchester |
see Bootlegs |
| 04-05-78 |
Ice Age |
RCA album sessions |
Arrow Studios, Manchester |
see Bootlegs |
| 04-05-78 |
Warsaw |
RCA album sessions |
Arrow Studios, Manchester |
see Bootlegs |
| 20-09-78 |
Shadowplay |
Granada Reports |
Studio 2,Granada TV |
see Bootlegs |
| 31-01-79 |
Insight |
John Peel Sessions |
BBC Studios, London |
Strange Fruit '86 & '90 |
| 31-01-79 |
Transmission |
John Peel Sessions |
BBC Studios, London |
Strange Fruit '86 & '90 |
| 31-01-79 |
She's Lost Control |
John Peel Sessions |
BBC Studios, London |
Strange Fruit '86 & '90 |
| 04-03-79 |
Digital |
Genetic demo |
Eden Studios, London |
Unreleased/unfinished? |
| ??-04-79 |
Walked In Line* |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Strawberry Studios |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 04-06-79 |
Atrocity Exhibition |
Piccadilly Radio session |
Pennine Sound Studios |
see Bootlegs |
| 13-06-79 |
Transmission (live) |
Atmosphere CD (Facd 213) |
The Factory, Manchester |
Factory '88 (CD only) |
| ??-07-79 |
Transmission |
1st 'Transmission' session |
Central Sound Studios |
see Bootlegs |
| ??-07-79 |
Novelty |
1st 'Transmission' session |
Central Sound Studios |
see Bootlegs |
| 20-07-79 |
She's Lost Control |
What's On, Granada TV |
Granada TV Studios |
Bootleg audio tape |
| 15-09-79 |
Transmission |
Complete BBC Recordings |
Something Else, BBC 2 TV |
Strange Fruit 2000 |
| 15-09-79 |
She's Lost Control |
Complete BBC Recordings |
Something Else, BBC 2 TV |
Strange Fruit 2000 |
| 26-10-79 |
The Sound Of Music |
John Peel Sessions |
BBC Studios, London |
Strange Fruit '87 & '90 |
| 26-10-79 |
Twenty Four Hours |
John Peel Sessions |
BBC Studios, London |
Strange Fruit '87 & '90 |
| ??-01-80 |
Love Will Tear Us Apart |
7"&12" (Fac 23) B-side |
Pennine Sound Studios |
Factory 1980 |
| 02-04-80 |
Sister Ray (live) |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Moonlight Club, London |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 28-04-80 |
Love Will Tear Us Apart |
promo video live soundtrack |
TJ Davidson's Studios |
Bootleg audio/video |
| 02-05-80 |
Ceremony |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
Shadowplay |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
A Means To An End |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
Passover |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
New Dawn Fades |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
Twenty Four Hours |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
Transmission |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
Disorder |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
Isolation |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
Decades |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| 02-05-80 |
Digital |
Still double LP (Fact 40) |
Birmingham University |
Factory '81 & '89(CD) |
| ??-??-95 |
Love Will Tear Us Apart |
LWTUA 1995 12"&CD |
Don Gehman remix |
London Records |
| ??-??-95 |
Love Will Tear Us Apart |
LWTUA 1995 12" |
Arthur Baker remix |
London Records |
--------
So is there still more? Yes, the following material is not included in the above listing;
- ??/04/1979 'Candidate' and 'New Dawn Fades' remixes. These are not confirmed as genuine, and have only turned
up on tape and vinyl bootlegs
- ??/09/1979 "Rock On", Radio 1, Ian Curtis, Steve Morris & Martin Hannett interview (available
on the "Complete BBC Recordings" CD, without the Hannett interview part)
- 15/09/1979 "Something Else", BBC 2 TV, interview with Steve Morris, Tony Wilson and others
- ??/11/1979 Castle Pub(?), Manchester, Ian Curtis interview (available on 7" & 12" Interview
picture disc)
- ??/04/1980 Radio Blackburn, Ian Curtis interview
- ??/??/1980 'She's Lost Control' extended version (longer intro), reportedly available on the Dutch or BeNeLux
1980 pressing of the "Atmosphere" 12"
- ??/??/1984 'Twenty Four Hours' remix, not confirmed as genuine, and incomplete
- ??/??/19?? 'Love Will Tear Us Apart' - "Trouser Enthusiasts" remix, London/DMC, available
on promo(?) 12" and CD remix compilation(?)
- "Preston 28 February 1980" CD NMC FACD 2.60, 1999
- "Le Bains Douches 18 December 1979" CD NMC FACD 2.61, 2001
Note: Bold letters mean this is an official release