|
Joy Division's Unknown
Pleasures (33 1/3)
Published: May 2004
117 pages
Publisher: Continuum Publishing Group
ISBN: 0826415490
Contrary to some reports
this book isn't just about the Unknown Pleasures
album, although many pages are devoted to the
recording of that album and the various songs
committed to tape during the UP sessions.
There are plenty of details about how Martin Hannett
created the Unknown Pleasures album's unique sound
through his "revolutionary" production technique, such
as the gadgets he used, etc. A bit technical at times,
but interesting nonetheless, even if much of this has
been covered in previous publications. We also get the
full JD story from the early punk days of Stiff
Kittens/Warsaw up until the final days of the band and
Ian's suicide.
According to this book
Bernard Sumner often refuses to acknowledge that JD
were ever known as Warsaw. Rather odd, as it's even
stated on the An Ideal For Living 7"EP sleeve - which
Barney designed if I'm not much mistaken - that "up
until the recording date of this E.P. we were known as
WARSAW".
Rather unavoidably, a lot of the information is taken
from other sources, in particular Touching From A
Distance, which of course offers the best glimpse into
Ian's personal life outside of the band.
Ott discusses the reasons
behind Ian's suicide and his state of mind, and also
tries to place Ian's lyrics into a broader literary
context. This review is based on an advance proof copy
so minor inaccuracies, like the 1st Peel session
having been recorded on 13th rather than 31st of
January in 1979, will hopefully have been corrected
when the finalised version goes on sale.
Chris Ott has written interesting articles about Joy
Division (and others) on Pitchforkmedia.com, but
whether his style and approach work as well in a book
format of this kind is another matter. Although rather
opinionated at times (e.g. Wilderness being the
weakest track on Unknown Pleasures? I think not), it's
a quick read, and enjoyable for the most part.
The relatively low asking price shouldn't discourage
anyone from picking it up. New fans will find it to be
a useful introduction to the band as it details
their story from the very beginning to the tragic end.
Even the more dedicated fan might be interested in
reading another person's opinions about the different
songs, the importance of JD's music, and why the band
still plays an important role in the history of
alternative music.
|
|
|
|